By Peter Marcus, DENVER DAILY NEWS
The daughter of a union boss ousted this week by grocery workers is defending the use of membership dues to challenge the results of the election her father lost.
Crisanta Duran, who serves as both general counsel and secretary-treasurer for the United Food and Commercial Workers Local 7, said Ernie Duran Jr., the longtime president of the union, lost his re-election bid because of defamation spread by his opponent, Kim Cordova.
Cordova targeted Ernie Duran as a corrupt union boss using union dues for personal gain and of nepotism for hiring several family members to high-paying positions paying more than $100,000 per year. The story was picked up by KMGH-Channel 7 in an investigative piece that revealed the union boss spending dues on expensive international trips, lavish dinners and Broncos tickets, to name a few.
But Crisanta Duran Wednesday defended the spending, arguing that every penny was approved by an executive board and an audit committee within the union itself. She said all the expenses were for official business, such as the Broncos tickets that were used as a winning prize in a raffle played by union membership.
“All union expenses have been legitimate and they have been approved by our executive board, our audit committee and also voted on at all of our membership meetings throughout the state,” Duran told reporters during a media briefing at the UFCW Local 7 building in Wheat Ridge. “We have a very transparent process, and just once again, they were all legitimate and approved.”
Cordova, however, used the expense reports and the fact that Ernie Duran has hired his daughter and son to high-paying union positions as fodder to advance her campaign.
From the Web site, VoteErnieOut.com, Cordova and her supporters have posted receipts from expensive dinners at Gaetano’s, Cuba Cuba Cafe and Bar, and Red Lobster — all paid with union dues. The union boss is portrayed as Ernie from “Sesame Street,” and membership is asked to vote out the “Duran Clan.”
Outrage
Cordova’s supporters are outraged that the Duran family is challenging the recent election, describing the union family as “sore losers.” Of most concern to Cordova’s supporters is that the Durans are using union dues to challenge the election in which membership decided to vote them out.
A robocall and text messages went out this week asking membership to report if they hadn’t received a ballot, indicating to membership that its current leadership plans on challenging the election to the U.S. Department of Labor.
Critics say union dues should not be spent on fighting an election that union bosses lost at the hands of their membership.
But Crisanta Duran said the election was held under false pretexts, which has done membership a disservice, especially given ongoing contract negotiations between the union and Colorado’s three major grocery chains. King Soopers workers in the Denver metro area have voted to reject the company’s latest offer, though voting is expected to last through next week. Safeway workers have voted to re-authorize a strike, though it is more likely that the two bargaining teams will head back to the table before going on strike. Negotiations with Albertson’s is ongoing.
Duran said it is acceptable to use union dues to fight for her and her family’s positions because the overall challenge serves the needs of its membership.
“Members deserve to be part of a fair election, and when you have people going out and lying to them, using documents and saying that they were used for different reasons than what they actually were, and lying to members about how and why union funds were spent — the members deserve to be able to have a fair election,” she said.
The challenge also points out that only 13 percent of members voted and that the election was very tight. Before taking the challenge to the Labor Department, it can be brought within 15 days to the international UFCW organization for a decision on whether another election is warranted. If the union as a whole chooses not to authorize another election, then the challenge can still be brought to the Labor Department.
Cordova set to take over Jan. 1
Cordova, a former union representative before she was fired by the union, is set to take over as president on Jan. 1. She would become the first woman president of the Colorado union. Cordova alleges that she was wrongfully terminated, but union officials will not comment on why she was fired from her position, stating that Cordova would need to sign a release to allow them to release records.
Crisanta Duran says the union has asked Cordova to sign the release, but that she refuses to do so.
Also decided in the election, Cindy Lucero, who ran on Cordova’s slate, is set to replace Crisanta Duran. Nineteen of 25 board members who ran as part of Cordova’s team were also backed by membership.
In addition to 17,000 grocery workers, Local 7 represents approximately 6,000 meatpacking and private-health-care workers.
Investigation
Meanwhile, the Labor Department is investigating whether Local 7 illegally spent union dues. While the Labor Department is not commenting on the investigation, Crisanta Duran said an audit cleared them of all wrongdoing. She said an exit interview back in June indicated that the feds found no money was missing and that all expenditures were properly accounted for.
Adding fuel to this controversial fire, Crisanta Duran has accused Cordova of attempting to extort $350,000 from the Durans in exchange for her not running for president. The money would have come as part of a wrongful termination suit, but no action was taken.
Duran cites a letter written by Chris Osborne, a union member, who says that before a recent monthly make-up membership meeting began, he overheard Cordova confronting Ernie Duran about the extortion. But when asked to provide minutes from the meeting, Crisanta Duran said no minutes were taken.
Often accusing Colorado’s three major grocery chains of paying its executives high salaries while refusing to offer its workers even a living wage, Crisanta Duran defended her $133,410 salary, arguing that this year she gave up almost a third of her salary to “dedicate to the workers’ struggle in negotiations.” Duran added that her salary last year was actually $71,511 — but that is because she took six months off from work to campaign for Mark Udall, who ran a successful campaign for U.S. Senate.
Duran added that it is not uncommon for union leaders to hire family members to rank and file positions, pointing to Lucero who has her son working as a union representative and Cordova who added three pairs of family members to her slate.
“We’re not using union dues to fight the election results,” concluded Duran. “What we are doing is we are collecting statements with regard to the defamatory allegations against the organization as a whole.”
Distributed by Colorado Capitol Reporters